All-Time All-ODAC Award Winners
| Year | Player | Position | ODAC Team | |
| 1977 | Fred Selfe | ODAC Coach of the Year | ||
| 1979 | Kevin Shinault | Catcher | First Team | |
| 1980 | Mike Keating | First Base | First Team | |
| 1981 | Kelly Carnahan | Outfield | First Team | |
| 1982 | Kelly Carnahan | Outfield | First Team | |
| 1983 | Wayne Hall | Third Base | First Team | |
| 1984 | Mike Lindsay | Outfield | First Team | |
| 1985 | Mike Lindsay | Outfield | First Team | |
| 1986 | Mike Lindsay | Outfield | First Team | |
| 1990 | Chip Lockhart | Designated Hitter | First Team | |
| 1992 | Chip Lockhart | Designated Hitter | First Team | |
| 1993 | Brett Clark | Shortstop | First Team | |
| Cary Perkins | Outfield | First Team | ||
| 1995 | Jared Beck | Catcher | First Team | |
| Brett Clark | Shortstop | First Team | ||
| 1996 | Jared Beck | Catcher | First Team | ODAC Player of the Year |
| Andy Dewease | Outfield | First Team | ||
| 1998 | Jason M. Austin | Catcher | First Team | |
| Brandon Matheny | Pitcher | First Team | ||
| Dewey Lusk | ODAC Coach of the Year | |||
| 1999 | Paul Sipos | Third Base | First Team | |
| John Sawyers | Outfield | First Team | ||
| 2000 | John Sawyers | Outfield | First Team | |
| 2006 | Adam Hall | First Base | Second Team | |
| 2008 | Gavin Haynes | Shortstop | Second Team | |
| 2012 | Josh McMillian | Second Base | First Team | |
| Remington Hedgepeth | Outfield | First Team | ||
| Collin Metz | Catcher | Second Team | ||
| Logan Ball | First Base | Third Team | ||
| Trey McCall | ODAC Coach of the Year | |||
| 2013 | Eric Houff | Outfield | Second Team | |
| Connor Wise | Catcher | Second Team | ||
| 2015 | Bransen Christopher | First Baseman | Second Team | |
| 2016 | Brandon Lineberry | Outfield | First Team | |
| Carson Bryant | First Baseman | Second Team | ||
| Holden Watkins | Shortstop | Third Team | ||
| 2017 | Logan Forster | First Baseman | Third Team | |
| Josh Macek | Outfield | Third Team | ||
| Ben Sexton | Outfield | Third Team | ||
| 2018 | Holden Watkins | Shortstop | Third Team | |
| Ben Sexton | Outfield | Third Team | ||
| 2019 | Ben Sexton | Outfield | First Team | |
| Corbin Hockensmith | Designated Hitter | Third Team | ||
| 2021 | Jared Foley | Outfield | Second Team | |
| Chandler Kezele | Designated Hitter | Second Team |
* Prior to 2012, the ODAC only recognized two all-conference teams. Second-team information in unavailable prior to the 2006 season.
-