All-Time All-ODAC Award Winners
| Year | Player | Position | ODAC Team |
| 1983 | Joe Cross | #3 Singles | ODAC Champion |
| Glenn Mosseller | #5 Singles | ODAC Champion | |
| 1984 | Rick Richardson | #6 Singles | ODAC Champion |
| 2003 | Al Morris | #5 Singles | Second Team |
| Wes Martin | #6 Singles | Second Team | |
| Aaron Richardson/Al Morris | #3 Doubles | Second Team | |
| 2007 | Dan Mansmann | #1 Singles | Second Team |
| 2008 | Ben Blevins | #1 Singles | First Team |
| Dan Mansmann | #2 Singles | Second Team | |
| Ben Blevins/Dan Mansmann | #1 Doubles | Second Team | |
| 2009 | Ben Blevins | #1 Singles | Second Team |
| Chip Wintringham | #2 Singles | First Team | |
| Kelly McCall | #3 Singles | Second Team | |
| Ben Blevins/Chip Wintringham | #1 Doubles | Second Team | |
| 2010 | Chip Wintringham | #1 Singles | Second Team |
| 2011 | Matt Nelson | #3 Singles | Second Team |
| Matt Nelson/Chip Wintringham | #1 Doubles | First Team | |
| 2012 | Chip Wintringham | #2 Singles | Second Team |
| Matt Nelson/Adam Henderson | #1 Doubles | First Team | |
| Chip Wintringham/Mike Young | #2 Doubles | Second Team | |
| 2013 | James Keighley | #1 Singles | Second Team |
| Alex Minasyan | #2 Singles | Third Team | |
| Matt Nelson | #3 Singles | Third Team | |
| Adam Henderson | #4 Singles | Third Team | |
| Webster Gilley | #5 Singles | Second Team | |
| Zach Eccher | #6 Singles | Third Team | |
| Matt Nelson/Adam Henderson | #1 Doubles | Second Team | |
| James Keighley/Webster Gilley | #2 Doubles | Second Team |
* Prior to 2007, the All-Conference teams were selected based on individual tournament play.
All-Time All-SAC Award Winners
| Year | Player | Position | SAC Team |
| 2024 | Kartik Parhar | #1 Singles | First Team |