All-Time All-ODAC Award Winners
| Year | Player | Position | ODAC Team | |
| 1995 | Stuart Wojunicki | Defender | First Team | |
| Philip McNamara | Midfielder | First Team | ||
| 1996 | Philip McNamara | Midfielder | First Team | |
| 1997 | Kareem Omary | Forward | First Team | |
| 2001 | Danny Almond | Forward | First Team | |
| 2005 | Elliot Anderson | Defender | ODAC Rookie of the Year | |
| 2006 | Elliot Anderson | Defender | First Team | |
| 2007 | Chris O'Conner | Defender | Second Team | |
| 2008 | P.J. Henson | Forward | Second Team | |
| 2015 | Jordan Couch | Forward | Second Team | |
| Tyequis Stallins | Forward | Third Team | ||
| 2016 | Jordan Couch | Forward | Second Team | |
| Tyequis Stallins | Forward | Third Team | ||
| 2018 | Tyequis Stallins | Forward | Third Team |
* Second Team members prior to 2006 are not available.
* The ODAC began recognizing a Third Team in the 2011 season.