All-Time All-ODAC Award Winners
| Year | Player | Position | ODAC Team | |
| 1996 | Shane Branum | DP | First Team | |
| 1997 | Ann Pickett | 1B | First Team | |
| 1998 | Kristi Maupin | SS | First Team | |
| 2001 | Sarah Cordill | SS | First Team | |
| 2002 | Sarah Cordill | SS | First Team | ODAC Player of the Year |
| Katie Dowe | C | Second Team | ||
| 2003 | Sarah Cordill | SS | First Team | |
| Mandy Smith | OF | First Team | ||
| 2004 | Sarah Cordill | SS | First Team | |
| Ashley Neese | OF | First Team | ||
| Sarah Caldwell | P | First Team | ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year | |
| 2005 | Brooke Barker | SS | First Team | |
| 2007 | Shannon Harris | P | Second Team | |
| 2013 | Hannah Bays | 3B | First Team | |
| Ashley Ebersole | C | Second Team | ||
| 2014 | Roxanne Hillman | DP | Second Team | |
| Jordan Chrisley | C | Third Team | ||
| Taylor Doss | 1B | Third Team | ||
| Ragan Halsey | 3B | Third Team | ||
| 2015 | Leah Elswick | OF | First Team | |
| Caley Hodge | 3B | Third Team | ||
| Danielle Loving | OF | Third Team | ||
| 2016 | Caley Hodge | DP | First Team | |
| 2017 | Danielle Loving | SS | First Team | ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year |
| Emily Kendrick | P | First Team | ||
| Caley Hodge | 1B | Second Team | ||
| Leah Elswick | 2B | Second Team | ||
| Amanda Whitlow | C | Second Team | ||
| 2018 | Erin Anderson | OF | First Team | ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year |
| Caley Hodge | 1B | Second Team | ||
| Amanda Whitlow | AL (C) | Second Team | ||
| Lyndsay Boyd | AL (2B) | Third Team | ||
| Leah Elswick | AL (SS) | Third Team | ||
| Madison McClanahan | AL (OF) | Third Team | ||
| 2019 | Kendall Varner | 1B | First Team | |
| Anna Thomas | OF | Second Team | ODAC Rookie of the Year | |
| Cameron Derr | P | Second Team | ||
| Leanna Toler | AL (SS) | Second Team | ||
| Erin Anderson | AL (OF) | Third Team | ||
| Alex Braun | AL (P) | Third Team | ||
| Madison McClanahan | AL (OF) | Third Team | ||
| 2021 | Alex Braun | DP | First Team | |
| Alex Braun | AL (P) | First Team | ||
| Nicole Cox | OF | First Team | ||
| Dacey Jenkins | AL (C) | Third Team |
* Second Team members from before 2007 are not available
^ In 2012, the ODAC began recognizing three All-ODAC Teams
# In 2018, the ODAC began using a modified at-large process for its teams.
All-Time Louisville Slugger/NFCA Award Winners
| NCAA Division III Era (1995-21) | |||
| Year | Player | Position | Team |
| 2001 | Sarah Cordill | AL (SS) | Third Team All-Atlantic Region |
| 2002 | Sarah Cordill | SS | First Team All-Atlantic Region |
| Katie Dowe | C | Second Team All-Atlantic Region | |
| Alex Marshman | DP | Second Team All-Atlantic Region | |
| 2003 | Mandy Smith | OF | Second Team All-America |
| First Team All-Atlantic Region | |||
| Sarah Cordill | SS | First Team All-Atlantic Region | |
| 2004 | Sarah Cordill | AL (SS) | First Team All-Atlantic Region |
| Sarah Caldwell | AL (P) | Third Team All-Atlantic Region | |
| 2013 | Hannah Bays | AL (3B) | Third Team All-Atlantic Region |
| 2017 | Emily Kendrick | P | Second Team All-Atlantic Region |
| Caley Hodge | 1B | Second Team All-Atlantic Region | |
| Danielle Loving | AL (SS) | Third Team All-Atlantic Region | |
| 2018 | Caley Hodge | AL (1B) | Third Team All-Atlantic Region |
| 2019 | Kendall Varner | AL (1B) | Third Team All-Atlantic Region |
| Anna Thomas | AL (OF) | Third Team All-Atlantic Region | |
| 2021 | Alex Braun | UT/P | First Team All-America |
| First Team All-Atlantic Region | |||
|
NCAA Division II Era (2022- |
|||
| 2022 | Lydia Taylor | SS | Second Team All-Southeast Region |
-