| 1995 - (1-15, 1-15 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Dave Franks |
||||
| Bridgewater* | A | L, 0-12 | L, 0-5 | |
| Lynchburg* | A | L, 0-10 | L, 0-14 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan* | H | L, 1-14 | L, 2-12 | |
| Eastern Mennonite* | H | L, 10-22 | W, 6-4 | |
| Bridgewater* | H | L, 0-12 | L, 0-10 | |
| Lynchburg* | H | L, 1-30 | L, 3-22 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan* | A | L, 0-11 | L, 0-11 | |
| Eastern Mennonite* | A | L, 2-29 | L, 0-7* |
(*forfeit) |
| 1996 - (0-18, 0-16 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Dave Franks |
||||
| Ferrum | A | L, 2-15 | L, 0-9 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | L, 1-10 | L, 1-22 | |
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 0-12 | L, 0-16 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | L, 0-14 | L, 2-12 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | L, 0-9 | L, 0-10 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 0-12 | L, 0-16 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 1-10 | L, 1-12 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 0-15 |
L, 2-15 |
|
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | L, 1-2 |
L, 1-9 |
|
| 1997 - (2-10, 0-8 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Dave Franks |
||||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | H | L, 0-13 | L, 4-14 | |
| Roanoke * | A | L, 5-6 | L, 1-9 | |
| Roanoke | H | L, 2-11 | L, 3-8 | |
| Virginia Intermont | H | W, 12-7 | W, 8-0 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | L, 1-10 | L, 13-21 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | L, 1-17 | L, 0-11 | |
| 1998 - (4-18, 0-8 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| Kenyon |
H | W, 13-5 | W, 24-10 | |
| Clinch Valley | H | W, 11-7 | L, 5-7 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
H | L, 0-3 | L, 1-15 | |
| Clinch Valley | A | W, 8-7 | L, 4-12 | |
| Roanoke * | H | L, 2-17 | L, 0-2 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | L, 3-11 | L, 0-7 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 3-9 | L, 1-9 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | N | L, 2-11 | L, 6-21 | |
| Roanoke | A | L, 2-3 | L, 0-8 | |
| Pikeville |
A | L, 1-3 | L, 5-7 | |
| Ferrum | A | L, 2-10 | L, 1-10 | |
| 1999 - (15-21, 7-7 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
A | L, 2-8 | L, 11-12 | |
| Averett | A | L, 4-7 | L, 8-10 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 1-12 | L, 3-10 | |
| St. Thomas Aquinas | N | W, 12-5 | ||
| Methodist | N | L, 5-8 | ||
| Salisbury State | N | L, 0-14 | ||
| Savannah Art & Design |
N | W, 9-4 | ||
| Southern Virginia | N | L, 4-8 | ||
| Tusculum | H | L, 1-5 | L, 8-10 | |
| Methodist | N | L, 3-6 | ||
| St. Joseph's-Long Island |
N | W, 5-2 | ||
| Averett | N | W, 4-2 | ||
| Randolph-Macon * | A | W, 10-8 | W, 8-4 | |
| Mary Washington | A | L, 7-8 | L, 5-13 | |
| Roanoke * | A | L, 0-6 | L, 7-8 | |
| Ferrum | H | W, 5-3 | L, 7-9 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | W, 14-3 | W, 11-6 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | L, 1-6 | L, 3-4 | |
| Pikeville |
H | L, 6-9 | W, 9-6 | |
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 10-14 | W, 4-3 | |
| R-M Woman's * | H | W, 10-9 | W, 13-3 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
H | W, 11-10 | W, 8-3 | |
| 2000 - (16-19, 6-8 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| Virginia Intermont | H | L, 4-6 | W, 8-7 | |
| Tusculum | A | L, 3-11 | L, 1-6 | |
| Agnes Scott | A | W, 7-0 | W, 16-2 | |
| LaGrange | A | L, 1-7 | L, 5-19 | |
| Elizabethtown | N | L, 0-1 | ||
| St. Joseph's-Long Island |
N | W, 10-1 | ||
| Shenandoah | N | W, 15-10 | ||
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
N | W, 4-3 | ||
| Ursinus |
N | L, 2-10 | ||
| Baptist Bible | H | W, 21-3 | W, 9-1 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | W, 32-3 | W, 13-0 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
H | L, 6-10 | W, 5-3 | |
| Roanoke * | H | L, 1-8 | L, 0-10 | |
| Southern Virginia | H | W, 6-2 | L, 1-14 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | N | L, 2-25 | L, 12-28 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | L, 1-12 | L, 4-15 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | W, 15-14 | W, 4-0 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 8-11 | L, 3-4 | |
| R-M Woman's * | A | W, 10-4 | W, 8-4 | |
| Ferrum | A | L, 2-8 | L, 1-9 | |
| 2001 - (24-15, 8-6 ODAC) |
ODAC Tournament |
|||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| Virginia Intermont | A | W, 10-1 | L, 2-6 | |
| Southern Virginia | A | W, 11-2 | W, 17-0 | |
| Rowan |
N | W, 5-4 | ||
| Christopher Newport | N | L, 3-11 | ||
| Mary Washington | N | W, 3-0 | ||
| Salisbury State | N | L, 2-10 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | W, 7-3 | L, 0-10 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | W, 10-4 | W, 11-3 | |
| Southern Virginia | N | W, 11-8 | ||
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
N | W, 11-2 | ||
| Shenandoah | N | W, 14-0 | ||
| Greensboro | N | L, 2-3 | ||
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 2-8 | L, 1-7 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
A | L, 5-10 | W, 6-2 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | W, 8-0 | W, 8-2 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | W, 3-0 | L, 1-9 | |
| Virginia Intermont | H | W, 4-2 | L, 4-7 | |
| Ferrum | H | W, 5-3 | L, 2-4 | |
| Milligan | N | W, 10-7 | ||
| Salem | H | W, 31-1 | ||
| Southern Virginia | H | W, 6-2 | ||
| R-M Woman's * | H | W, 13-5 | W, 11-3 | |
| Roanoke * | A | L, 0-1 | L, 2-10 | |
| Lynchburg ^ | N | L, 1-3 | ||
| Bridgewater ^ | N | W, 5-1 | ||
| Lynchburg ^ | N | W, 4-3 | ||
| Roanoke ^ | N | L, 1-9 | ||
| 2002 - (32-12-1, 9-5 ODAC) |
ODAC Tournament |
|||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| Milligan | A | W, 8-7 | W, 8-2 | |
| Emory | N | L, 1-11 | ||
| Mountain State | N | W, 8-7 | ||
| Christopher Newport | N | W, 7-6 | ||
| Methodist | A | L, 2-3 | ||
| North Carolina Wesleyan | N | W, 7-0 | ||
| Peace | A | W, 4-3 | W, 9-1 | |
| Greensboro | A | W, 13-0 | W, 6-0 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | H | W, 3-1 | W, 11-7 | |
| Southern Virginia | N | W, 6-3 | ||
| Gallaudet | N | W, 9-0 | ||
| St. Joseph's-Long Island |
N | W, 13-0 | ||
| Frostburg State | N | W, 3-0 | ||
| Eastern Mennonite * |
A | W, 24-0 | W, 11-1 |
|
| UVA-Wise | A | W, 7-6 | T, 0-0 | |
| Ferrum | N | W, 4-3 | L, 1-4 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | W, 10-0 | W, 14-0 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | L, 2-5 | W, 8-0 | |
| Virginia Intermont | A | L, 4-5 | W, 11-3 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
H | W, 6-2 | L, 3-10 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 0-2 | L, 2-5 | |
| R-M Women's * | A | W, 15-0 | W, 13-2 | |
| Roanoke * | H | L, 4-7 | L, 2-3 | |
| Southern Virginia | H | W, 6-0 | W, 4-1 | |
| Bluefield | H | W, 3-2 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | W, 3-2 | ||
| Roanoke ^ | N | L, 4-5 | ||
| Eastern Mennonite ^ | N | W, 6-1 | ||
| Lynchburg ^ | N | L, 9-10 | ||
| 2003 - (22-12, 12-4 ODAC) |
ODAC Champions |
|||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | NCAA Tournament |
|||
| Salisbury | N | L, 0-2 | ||
| Wilkes |
N | L, 6-7 | ||
| Moravian | N | L, 3-8 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | W, 4-0 | W, 4-2 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | W, 8-0 | W, 8-2 | |
| Ferrum | N | W, 3-2 | ||
| Frostburg State | N | W, 12-7 | ||
| Randolph-Macon | N | W, 8-1 | ||
| Chowan | N | W, 11-4 | ||
| Emory | N | L, 0-5 | ||
| Salisbury | N | L, 2-6 | ||
| Averett | N | L, 2-12 | ||
| North Carolina Wesleyan | N | W, 8-3 | ||
| Roanoke * | A | L, 5-6 | L, 4-9 | |
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 0-4 | L, 0-3 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | W, 17-0 | W, 15-1 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | W, 3-0 | W, 5-4 | |
| Guilford * | A | W, 4-1 | W, 5-1 | |
| R-M Woman's * | N | W, 12-0 | W, 9-0 | |
| Guilford ^ | N | W, 8-0 | ||
| Lynchburg ^ | N | W, 5-2 | ||
| Roanoke ^ | N | W, 5-0 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | W, 2-0 | ||
| Millsaps % | N | W, 7-5 | ||
| Emory % | N | L, 1-3 | ||
| Millsaps % | N | L, 0-4 | ||
| 2004 - (28-14, 10-6 ODAC) |
ODAC Tournament |
|||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| UVA-Wise | H | L, 3-8 | L, 0-11 | |
| Methodist | N | W, 2-0 | ||
| York (Pa.) |
N | W, 3-0 | ||
| Lynchburg | N | W, 4-0 | ||
| North Carolina Wesleyan | N | W, 2-0 | ||
| Edinboro |
N | W, 5-1 | ||
| Methodist | A | L, 2-3 |
W, 5-4 | |
| Huntingdon | H | L, 0-1 | W, 3-1 | |
| St. Joseph's-Long Island |
N | W, 12-0 | ||
| Meredith | N | W, 11-0 | ||
| Frostburg State |
N | W, 7-0 | ||
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
N | W, 7-6 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | H | W, 3-1 | W, 8-0 | |
| Averett | N | W, 5-2 | ||
| Bethany (W.Va.) |
N | W, 3-1 | ||
| Mary Washington | N | W, 4-0 | ||
| Roanoke | A | L, 1-5 | ||
| Marietta | N | W, 5-2 | ||
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 3-5 | L, 2-7 | |
| R-M Woman's * | A | W, 13-0 | W, 11-0 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
A | L, 1-2 | W, 6-1 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | L, 2-3 | W, 11-0 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | W, 5-0 | L, 0-5 | |
| Roanoke * | H | L, 4-9 | L, 1-3 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | W, 1-0 | W, 8-0 | |
| Guilford * | H | W, 8-2 | W, 8-1 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
N | W, 5-1 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | L, 1-2 | ||
| Bridgewater ^ | N | W, 4-2 | ||
| Lynchburg ^ | N | L, 0-1 | ||
| 2005 - (13-17, 6-10 ODAC) |
ODAC Tournament |
|||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| Lycoming | N | L, 0-1 | ||
| North Carolina Wesleyan | N | W, 8-4 | ||
| Salisbury | N | L, 0-2 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 0-3 | W, 1-0 | |
| Concordia-Moorhead | N | W, 7-0 | ||
| Millikin | N | L, 3-8 | ||
| Macalester | N | W, 12-0 | ||
| Washington & Jefferson | N | W, 3-2 | ||
| Ramapo | N | L, 0-2 | ||
| Wisconsin-Platteville | N | W, 4-1 | ||
| Roanoke * | A | L, 0-8 | L, 0-4 | |
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 1-9 | L, 9-11 | |
| UVA-Wise | A | W, 4-0 | L, 0-1 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | W, 7-3 | L, 3-6 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | W, 7-0 | L, 2-3 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | W, 12-4 | L, 4-5 | |
| Guilford * | A | L, 0-1 | L, 2-9 | |
| R-M Women's * | H | W, 18-0 | W, 12-0 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | L, 5-6 | ||
| Bridgewater ^ | N | W, 4-1 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | L, 0-8 | ||
| 2006 - (18-23-1, 12-6 ODAC) | ODAC Tournament |
|||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| Tusculum | A | L, 0-13 | T, 1-1 | |
| Virginia Intermont | A | W, 5-3 | L, 3-4 | |
| Southern Virginia | H | L, 0-2 | ||
| UVA-Wise | H | W, 1-0 | L, 1-3 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | W, 8-3 | W, 9-1 | |
| Virginia Intermont | H | L, 2-6 | ||
| Emory | A | L, 4-5 | ||
| LaGrange | A | L, 5-6 | W, 7-3 | |
| Piedmont | A | L, 0-1 | W, 2-1 | |
| Milligan | H | L, 5-7 | ||
| Ferrum | N | W, 4-3 | ||
| Frostburg State | N | L, 1-4 | ||
| Ohio Valley | N | L, 5-6 | ||
| Shenandoah | N | L, 0-3 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | H | W, 2-1 | L, 4-7 | |
| R-M Women's * | A | W, 12-0 | W, 9-1 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | L, 2-4 | W, 9-3 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | L, 7-8 | L, 2-5 | |
| King (Tenn.) |
H | L, 8-9 | ||
| Lynchburg * | A | W, 6-2 | L, 1-10 |
|
| Sweet Briar * | H | W, 11-1 | W, 6-1 | |
| Guilford * | H | W, 4-2 | W, 3-2 | |
| Roanoke * | H | W, 1-0 | L, 1-9 | |
| Milligan | N | L, 4-9 | ||
| Lynchburg ^ | N | W, 2-1 | ||
| Bridgewater ^ | N | L, 5-7 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | L, 4-9 | ||
| 2007 - (23-21, 11-7 ODAC) |
ODAC Tournament |
|||
| Head Coach: Shannon Farley | ||||
| Piedmont | N | L, 4-6 | ||
| Huntingdon |
N | L, 2-5 | ||
| Mary Washington | N | W, 3-0 | ||
| Salisbury | N | L, 0-7 | ||
| Averett | N | W, 1-0 | ||
| Christopher Newport | N | L, 1-3 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | W, 7-5 | W, 3-2 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | W, 1-0 | W, 6-4 | |
| Salem |
H | W, 30-1 | W, 14-2 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
H | L, 0-1 | L, 0-5 | |
| Coll. of New Jersey |
N | L, 1-2 | ||
| LaRoche | N | W, 4-3 | ||
| Shenandoah | N | W, 11-5 | ||
| Ferrum | N | W, 3-0 | ||
| Virginia Intermont | A | L, 3-15 | L, 1-2 | |
| Lynchburg * | H | W, 10-9 | L, 2-10 | |
| R-M Woman's * | H | W, 9-1 | W, 12-4 | |
| Greensboro | A | L, 3-4 | W, 1-0 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | L, 0-1 | L, 1-2 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | L, 0-6 | L, 1-5 | |
| UVA-Wise | A | L, 0-4 | L, 1-4 | |
| Roanoke * | A | L, 0-2 | L, 2-7 | |
| Guilford * | A | W, 2-0 | W, 5-4 | |
| King (Tenn.) |
N | W, 7-2 | ||
| Sweet Briar * | N | W, 6-0 | W, 7-0 | |
| Eastern Mennonite ^ | N | W, 1-0 | ||
| Bridgewater ^ | N | L, 1-9 | ||
| Randolph-Macon ^ | N | W, 8-0 | ||
| Eastern Mennonite ^ | N | W, 4-3 | ||
| Bridgewater ^ | N | L, 1-7 | ||
| 2008 - (10-24, 4-14 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Kristen Diamond | ||||
| Warner Southern | A | L, 4-9 | L, 0-5 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
A | L, 0-1 | L, 3-4 | |
| Greensboro | H | L, 5-6 | L, 4-8 | |
| Lycoming | N | W, 6-2 | ||
| Meredith | N | W, 15-4 | ||
| SUNY-Purchase | N | W, 18-2 | ||
| Ferrum | N | W, 2-1 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | H | L, 0-6 | L, 0-13 | |
| Guilford * | H | L, 3-4 | L, 6-11 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 1-2 | L, 2-5 | |
| Randolph * | A | W, 10-0 | W, 12-5 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | L, 2-7 | L, 0-9 | |
| Roanoke * | H | L, 0-4 | L, 1-11 | |
| Virginia Intermont | H | W, 5-4 | W, 9-8 | |
| Sweet Briar * | H | L, 4-5 | W, 6-2 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | L, 0-3 | L, 0-8 | |
| UVA-Wise | H | L, 0-8 | L, 0-8 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | W, 3-0 | L, 4-7 | |
| Milligan | N | L, 0-1 | ||
| King (Tenn.) |
N | L, 7-9 | ||
| 2009 - (4-24, 1-15 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Kristen Diamond | ||||
| Greensboro | A | L, 0-3 | L, 4-12 | |
| Virginia Intermont | H | L, 6-7 | L, 0-12 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
H | L, 1-2 | L, 2-17 | |
| Arcadia |
N | L, 0-3 | ||
| Franklin & Marshall | N | W, 7-5 | ||
| Albright |
N | W, 5-1 | ||
| Cabrini |
N | W, 6-5 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 1-5 | L, 2-7 | |
| Virginia Intermont | A | L, 1-6 | L, 10-13 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | L, 0-8 | L, 3-11 | |
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 0-13 | L, 3-15 | |
| Randolph * | H | L, 3-8 | L, 5-13 | |
| Guilford * | A | L, 0-1 | L, 4-11 | |
| Sweet Briar * | A | W, 6-1 | L, 1-6 | |
| Roanoke * | A | L, 0-2 | L, 7-8 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | L, 2-3 | L, 3-15 | |
| 2010 - (3-21, 3-15 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Kristen Diamond | ||||
| Virginia Intermont | H | L, 1-17 | L, 2-12 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | N | L, 0-13 | L, 2-15 | |
| Ferrum | A | L, 0-10 | L, 1-9 | |
| Maryville (Tenn.) |
A | L, 0-14 | L, 5-10 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 0-21 | L, 5-14 | |
| Randolph * | A | L, 5-23 | W, 12-11 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | L, 3-6 | L, 1-19 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | L, 1-9 | L, 2-11 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | L, 0-15 | L, 0-14 | |
| Guilford * | H | L, 3-16 | L, 0-10 | |
| Sweet Briar * | H | W, 11-3 | W, 6-5 | |
| Roanoke * | H | L, 3-27 | L, 1-17 | |
| 2011 - (10-24, 4-14 ODAC) | (all time series will count tie) |
|||
| Head Coach: Jack Jordan | ||||
| Washington (Md.) | N | L, 2-14 | ||
| Spalding |
N | T, 2-2* | (W, forfeit) | |
| John Jay | N | W, 14-0 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 2-14 | L, 1-14 | |
| York (N.Y.) | N | W, 28-0 | ||
| Averett | A | L, 2-8 | L, 5-13 | |
| Ferrum | N | L, 0-7 | ||
| Peace | N | L, 2-3 | ||
| Cazenovia | N | L, 1-4 | ||
| Castleton | N | L, 2-10 | ||
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 1-9 | L, 1-6 | |
| Randolph * | H | L, 2-11 | W, 9-7 | |
| Bluefield | A | W, 10-6 | W, 8-1 | |
| Guilford * | A | L, 1-9 | L, 1-13 | |
| Sweet Briar * | A | W, 11-0 | W, 16-0 | |
| Roanoke * | A | W, 6-0 | L, 0-5 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | L, 0-13 | L, 0-18 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | L, 0-3 | L, 0-12 | |
| Bluefield | H | L, 2-5 | W, 3-2 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | L, 1-10 | L, 4-10 | |
| Virginia Intermont | A | L, 1-4 | L, 0-10 | |
| 2012 - (14-24, 4-14 ODAC) |
ODAC Tournament |
|||
| Head Coach: Sara Schoenhoft | ||||
| King (Tenn.) |
A | L, 1-2 | L, 0-12 | |
| York (Pa.) | N | W, 11-5 | ||
| Greensboro | N | L, 5-6 | ||
| Stevenson | N | L, 1-2 | ||
| Methodist | A | L, 0-10 | ||
| North Carolina Wesleyan | A | L, 1-7 | ||
| Salem | A | L, 4-7 | W, 13-0 | |
| Averett | H | W, 4-2 | L, 0-7 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | H | L, 0-10 | L, 1-9 | |
| Bluefield | H | W, 9-7 | L, 8-11 | |
| Maine-Presque Isle | H | W, 10-0 | W, 5-0 | |
| Guilford * | H | L, 1-9 | W, 5-3 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 0-15 | L, 3-4 | |
| Randolph * | A | L, 3-4 | L, 2-3 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | L, 0-6 | L, 5-9 | |
| Bluefield | A | W, 11-2 | W, 11-3 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | L, 0-6 | W, 3-2 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | L, 1-6 | L, 1-10 | |
| Roanoke * | H | L, 1-4 | L, 1-9 | |
| Sweet Briar * | H | W, 15-2 | W, 27-1 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | L, 0-1 | ||
| Lynchburg ^ | N | W, 9-5 | ||
| Eastern Mennonite ^ | N | L, 0-10 | ||
| 2013 - (12-26, 4-16 ODAC) |
||||
| Head Coach: Sara Schoenhoft | ||||
| Mary Washington | N | L, 0-7 |
||
| Methodist | A | L, 1-4 | ||
| Rivier | N | L, 7-9 | ||
| Penn State-Fayette | N | W, 15-1 | ||
| Penn State-Altoona | N | W, 6-2 | ||
| Penn State-Beaver | N | W, 5-0 | ||
| Penn State-Berks | N | L, 3-7 | ||
| Green Mountain | N | W, 10-0 | ||
| Tennessee Wesleyan | N | L, 4-5 | ||
| Penn State-Fayette | N | W, 22-0 | ||
| Ferrum | A | L, 4-9 | L, 1-3 | |
| Bluefield | A | W, 12-5 | L, 5-6 | |
| Salem | H | W, 14-5 | W, 11-3 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | L, 2-10 | L, 1-4 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 8-9 | ||
| Sweet Briar * | A | W, 11-1 | W, 12-1 | |
| Roanoke * | A | L, 2-11 | L, 1-8 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | L, 8-10 | L, 6-10 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | L, 0-8 | L, 6-14 | |
| Virginia Intermont | H | L, 2-15 | L, 8-12 | |
| Shenandoah * | H | L, 2-16 | L, 2-6 | |
| Guilford * | A | W, 10-8 | L, 3-6 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 3-11 | ||
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 5-8 | L, 0-5 |
|
| Randolph * | H | W, 7-6 | L, 2-10 | |
| 2014 - (23-15, 9-11 ODAC) | ODAC Tournament | |||
| Head Coach: Tommy Forrester | ||||
| Virginia Intermont | A | L, 1-9 | W, 3-2 | |
| Southern Virginia | H | W, 9-0 | W, 9-0 | |
| North Carolina Wesleyan | A | W, 2-1 | W, 9-0 | |
| Blackburn | N | W, 11-3 | ||
| Medaille | N | W, 10-2 | ||
| Ohio Valley | N | W, 3-0 | ||
| Ursuline | N | W, 4-3 | ||
| Greenville | N | W, 6-5 | ||
| Eureka | N | W, 9-1 | ||
| Bay Path | N | W, 10-2 | ||
| Baptist Bible | N | W, 17-0 | ||
| Randolph-Macon * | H | L, 5-14 | L, 1-11 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | H | L, 2-10 | L, 1-10 | |
| Bluefield | H | L, 2-4 | W, 11-0 | |
| Roanoke * | H | W, 4-2 | L, 5-6 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | W, 6-4 | L, 3-8 | |
| Bridgewater * | A | W, 4-0 | W, 7-0 | |
| Shenandoah * | A | W, 10-8 | W, 4-1 | |
| Guilford * | H | L, 1-3 | W, 8-4 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 1-6 | L, 0-3 | |
| Sweet Briar * | H | W, 15-1 | W, 8-0 | |
| Randolph * | A | L, 0-3 | L, 5-7 | |
| Lynchburg ^ | N | L, 2-7 | ||
| Randolph ^ | N | L, 0-2 | ||
| 2015 - (26-12, 10-10 ODAC) | ODAC Tournament | |||
| Head Coach: Tommy Forrester | ||||
| Curry | N | W, 4-1 | ||
| Bethany Lutheran | N | W, 6-0 | ||
| Minnesota-Morris | N | W, 12-4 | ||
| Dominican (Ill.) | N | W, 6-0 | ||
| New Jersey City | N | W, 7-0 | ||
| Elms | N | W, 13-2 | ||
| Greensboro | H | W, 7-4 | W, 7-3 | |
| Sweet Briar * | H | W, 9-3 | W, 16 -3 | |
| Roanoke * | H | L, 0-12 | W, 2-1 | |
| Bluefield | A | W, 10-0 | W, 6-5 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | A | W, 11-9 | W, 4-3 | |
| Bridgewater * |
A | W, 1-0 | W, 13-6 | |
| Guilford * | A | W, 3-2 | W, 0-8 | |
| Lynchburg * | H | L, 0-7 | L, 4-14 | |
| Randolph * | A | L, 2-4 | W, 8-4 | |
| Ferrum | A | W, 12-7 | W, 7-3 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | H | L, 0-8 | L, 3-7 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | H | L, 0-1 | L, 3-4 | |
| Southern Virginia | A | W, 17-3 | ||
| Shenandoah * | A | W, 3-0 | L, 7-9 | |
| Roanoke ^ | N | L, 1-3 | ||
| Eastern Mennonite ^ | N | W, 2-1 | ||
| Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | W, 3-1 | ||
| Roanoke ^ | N | W, 4-1 | ||
| Lynchburg ^ | N | L, 1-2 | ||
| 2016 - (15-27, 7-11 ODAC) | ODAC Tournament | |||
| Head Coach: Tommy Forrester | ||||
| Centre | N | W, 8-2 | L, 2-3 | |
| Maryville | A | W, 11-6 | L, 0-6 | |
| Marietta | H | L, 2-3 | L, 8-10 | |
| Case Western Reserve | H | L, 8-16 | L, 2-7 | |
| Bluefield | H | W, 8-2 | L, 5-6 | |
| Lycoming | N | L, 2-3 | ||
| Medaille | N | L, 10-12 | ||
| Penn College | N | W, 5-1 | ||
| Chatham | N | W, 12-3 | ||
| Penn State-Altoona | N | W, 2-1 | ||
| La Roche | N | W, 10-1 | ||
| Piedmont | A | L, 1-7 | L, 0-8 | |
| Salem | A | L, 4-5 | L, 2-10 | |
| Randolph * | H | L, 5-8 | W, 13-11 | |
| Guilford * | H | W, 2-0 | W, 7-6 | |
| Eastern Mennonite * | H | L, 6-8 | L, 5-10 | |
| Bridgewater * | H | W, 12-9 | W, 8-2 | |
| Roanoke * | A | L, 3-8 | L, 0-6 | |
| Lynchburg * | A | L, 1-9 | L, 5-11 | |
| Ferrum | H | W, 6-4 | L, 2-4 | |
| Virginia Wesleyan * | A | L, 0-8 | L, 0-4 | |
| Randolph-Macon * | A | L, 1-3 | L, 1-9 | |
| Shenandoah * | H | W, 9-7 | W, 11-3 | |
| #1 Virginia Wesleyan ^ | N | L, 1-9 | ||
| #4 Lynchburg ^ | N | L, 1-9 | ||
-